By Isla Quinn
Snap it. Listen. Modica chocolate does not melt on the tongue like a smooth bar, and it is not meant to. It crunches, a little sandy, a little sweet, with the bitter edge of cocoa behind. That texture is the whole point, and since 2018 it has had a protected name to go with it.
What the name covers
Qualigeo, the European database of protected-origin foods run by the Qualivita foundation, describes Cioccolato di Modica IGP as chocolate made by working bitter cocoa paste with sugar. It says the production zone is the municipality of Modica, in the province of Ragusa, Sicily, and nowhere else. A bar made in another town, however it is styled, is outside that zone.
How it is made
The same page says the cocoa mass is melted, in a bain-marie or in melting-tempering machines, to a maximum of 50°C at the heart of the mass. The sugar is added after melting, with continuous mixing, and may be cane, refined or whole sugar. The mass is portioned into moulds and vibrated for one to three minutes. Packing must follow within 12 hours of taking the bars from the moulds. The consortium of producers says its chocolatiers work at low temperatures and avoid conching, the long grinding and heating step that smooths other chocolate. Wikipedia’s Italian article says skipping that step stops the sugar blending into the cocoa, so the bar stays granular. Qualigeo’s description says the process is worked cold, with temperature kept below the point where the sugar crystals melt, and does not mention conching at all.
Flavourings
Qualigeo lists salt, cinnamon, vanilla, chilli, nutmeg, citrus aroma, fennel, jasmine and ginger among the optional ingredients, and dried fruit and nuts such as pistachio, hazelnut, almond and citrus, with other spices and natural aromas also allowed. It says tempering is allowed before moulding.
What it looks like
Qualigeo gives the shape as a rectangular block with tapered sides, weighing no more than 100 grams. The paste is brown with visible granularity from the sugar crystals, it says, and cocoa butter may come to the surface. It describes the taste as sweet with a note of bitterness, a granular or sandy feel, good melting and a crunchy structure. It also says pieces of 25 grams, dissolved in hot water, make one cup of chocolate drink.
Where the sources disagree
Three numbers do not line up, and we show them side by side.
The heat. Qualigeo says a maximum of 50°C at the core of the mass. Wikipedia’s Italian article says mixing is kept at 35 to 40°C. The consortium’s page gives no figure. We do not choose.
The date of the mark. Qualigeo gives a registration date of 14 October 2018 and says the entry was published in the Official Journal of the European Union on 15 October 2018. Wikipedia says the mark was granted on 8 October 2018 by Regulation (EU) 2018/1529. The year agrees, and the day does not.
The origin. Wikipedia says some sources report that the Spanish brought the technique to the County of Modica in the sixteenth century, having learned cacao work from the Aztecs. A producer’s blog calls the Aztec origin a myth. Qualigeo gives a local history: chocolate made in noble households from the 1700s, with archives of the Grimaldi family documenting chocolatiers as early as 1746. The consortium’s site says its research found chocolatiers active from 1746 and uses “Unico dal 1746” as its tagline. None of the four reconciles the others.
Fresh, or built to last
The producer’s blog is the only source we read that argues over shelf life, and it is a producer’s opinion. It quotes the specification as allowing tempering before moulding, and says traditional untempered chocolate was meant to be eaten within a few weeks, while its own tempered bars carry an 18-month shelf life. Qualigeo says shelf life is about 18 months in a cool, dry place. The blog also says cocoa butter can rise to the surface and turn the bar white and crumbly, and calls that a defect. Wikipedia says the white bloom is common and does not change the traditional taste. The specification, as Qualigeo describes it, treats surface cocoa butter as something that may appear. Three views of one white film: defect, harmless, permitted.
What the label must show
According to Qualigeo, packs must show the name “Cioccolato di Modica”, the European IGP symbol and the product logo, and a unique alphanumeric code assigned by the control body. A security label printed by the Italian State Mint is voluntary.
Dates in order
- 1700s: chocolate made in noble households in Modica, according to Qualigeo.
- 1746: chocolatiers documented in the Grimaldi archives, according to Qualigeo and the consortium.
- 1800s: workshops serving the aristocracy, according to Wikipedia.
- 1992: the current method adopted, according to Wikipedia.
- 2003: the consortium formed, according to Wikipedia.
- October 2018: the protected name, according to Qualigeo and Wikipedia.
Side by side
The sources agree on the zone, on the absence of conching and on the grain. They differ on the temperature, the day of registration and the legend. Our reading: the origin story is the part of the product that is told most often and documented least. That is our inference and none of the sources states it.
What kind of sources these are
A database kept by a non-profit foundation; the consortium’s own website; Wikipedia’s Italian article; and one producer’s blog. The blog has a stake in the comparison it draws, and we treat it as that. We read neither the specification itself nor any retailer.
Questions a buyer would ask
Does the pack carry the name, the European symbol and the code? Is the bar a tempered one with a long shelf life, or an untempered one meant for the short term? A producer can answer both. We do not name a producer or a bar.
What we left out
We left out prices, cocoa origin, sales figures, the religious institutions Qualigeo mentions in its history, and the cocoa percentage Wikipedia gives, which we could not match to the specification. We found no source that sets rules for the cocoa itself, so we say nothing on it.
Quick answers
Where can Cioccolato di Modica IGP be made? According to Qualigeo, only in the municipality of Modica, in the province of Ragusa, Sicily.
Is Modica chocolate made without conching? The producers’ consortium says its chocolatiers avoid conching and work at low temperatures. Qualigeo does not mention a conching step.
Why is it grainy? Qualigeo says the paste shows visible granularity from sugar crystals, which are kept intact by the cold working.
Related on this site: mantua-gonzaga-palace-three-lakes-lombardy, cotechino-zampone-modena-igp-new-year, borsalino-hat-alessandria-felt
Roam first. Shop later.